Senate Issues Show Cause Order Against VP Spokesperson for Criticism of Senator-Judges

Manila:The Senate impeachment court has issued a show cause order against Vice President Sara Duterte's spokesperson, lawyer Paolo Panelo, following his criticisms of senator-judges. Panelo accused some judges of bias and acting like prosecutors during the ongoing trial.

According to Philippines News agency, Presiding Officer Senator Francis 'Chiz' Escudero approved a motion by Senator-Judge Erwin Tulfo without objection. This action requires Panelo to explain his remarks, which questioned the impartiality of certain impeachment court members. Panelo specifically named Senators Risa Hontiveros, Francis Pangilinan, and Raffy Tulfo, criticizing their questioning of defense witness Rainer Dela Fuente.

Panelo argued that it was the prosecution's role to challenge a witness's credibility and called for senator-judges to maintain impartiality. His remarks followed earlier criticisms of the prosecution, which he accused of attempting to sway public opinion against Duterte.

Senator Tulfo raised concerns about Panelo's public attacks on the credibility of senator-judges, noting that despite not being a party to the case, Panelo speaks for the vice president. Tulfo described Panelo's comments as disrespectful to the tribunal.

Escudero clarified that while Rule 18 of the impeachment court's sub judice rule does not apply to Panelo, as he is not a lawyer of record, witness, or party to the proceedings, Panelo could be accountable under Rule 71 of the Rules of Court concerning contempt proceedings.

Following Tulfo's formal motion, Escudero approved issuing the show cause order, which allows Panelo to explain his remarks without constituting a contempt finding.

Panelo's stance contrasts with that of defense panel spokesperson Michael Poa, who defended the senator-judges' rights to question and express views. The situation arises amid the defense's presentation of evidence related to allegations of at least PHP817.87 million in unexplained wealth linked to Duterte under Article II of the impeachment complaint.