Manila:Senator-judge Erwin Tulfo expressed criticism towards the quality of Vice President Sara Duterte's defense witnesses during an impeachment trial on Thursday. Several senator-judges questioned the capability of lawyer Rainer Dela Fuente in challenging a forensic report for which he had not been provided supporting documentation.
According to Philippines News agency, Tulfo highlighted the weaknesses in the witnesses presented by the defense, urging them to bring forth individuals capable of addressing substantive inquiries. He emphasized the importance of reviewing financial documents, particularly covered and suspicious transaction reports, to validate the testimony.
The questioning by Tulfo was followed by other senator-judges, including Raffy Tulfo and Joel Villanueva, who raised concerns about Dela Fuente's preparedness to counter the prosecution's financial findings. Dela Fuente was initially called to elaborate on legal concepts under the Anti-Money Laundering Act (AMLA).
Impeachment Presiding Officer Francis "Chiz" Escudero noted that Dela Fuente was not recognized as a constitutional expert, advising the defense to conclude their questioning on constitutional matters. Villanueva acknowledged Dela Fuente's role in explaining banking and anti-money laundering laws but pointed out that legal conclusions rest with appropriate authorities.
Villanueva did not object to Dela Fuente's testimony if it aimed to challenge the prosecution's financial expert, Alexander Cabrera. However, issues arose as the defense had not provided Dela Fuente with Cabrera's forensic report for review prior to the court proceedings.
Raffy Tulfo commented that the witness should have been better prepared by reviewing documents before rebutting the findings. Furthermore, Senator-judge Risa Hontiveros questioned Dela Fuente's ability to assess the forensic report's quality without reviewing the records used by Cabrera.
Dela Fuente defended his stance by referring to legal texts presented during the trial, despite acknowledging his lack of access to crucial documents.